Methodology
How we evaluate investment opportunities — our scoring frameworks, grading criteria, and analytical approach
Our Approach
Uncovering Value uses structured, repeatable scoring frameworks to evaluate investment opportunities. Each research area has its own methodology tailored to the specific factors that drive value in that category.
Grades are not subjective opinions. Each grade is the output of a weighted scorecard with defined dimensions, scored on a consistent scale, producing a final weighted score that maps to a letter grade.
Spinoff Investment Scorecard
Our spinoff analysis uses a five-dimension weighted scorecard to evaluate each upcoming spinoff opportunity.
Scoring Dimensions
| # | Dimension | Weight | What It Captures |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Financial Profile | 25% | Margins, growth rate, revenue scale, balance sheet health |
| 2 | Competitive Position | 25% | Moat, market share, pure-play dominance, industry structure |
| 3 | Strategic Rationale | 20% | Unlocking value vs. shedding a problem, clarity of thesis |
| 4 | Management & Governance | 20% | Leadership quality, CEO placement signal, incentive alignment |
| 5 | Acquisition Potential | 10% | Likelihood as takeout target, consolidating industry, strategic fit |
Financial Profile and Competitive Position together account for half the score. These are the strongest differentiators between top-tier and average spinoffs. Management carries significant weight because proper incentive alignment is critical to unlocking value in a newly independent company.
Scoring Scale
Each dimension is scored from 1 (Poor) to 5 (Exceptional).
Financial Profile (25%)
| Score | Description | Indicators |
|---|---|---|
| 5 | Exceptional | 30%+ EBITDA margins, double-digit revenue growth, clean balance sheet |
| 4 | Strong | 15–30% EBITDA margins, 5–10% growth, manageable leverage |
| 3 | Adequate | 10–15% margins, low-single-digit growth, moderate debt load |
| 2 | Weak | Sub-10% margins, flat or declining revenue, elevated leverage |
| 1 | Poor | Negative or minimal margins, secular decline, distressed balance sheet |
Competitive Position (25%)
| Score | Description | Indicators |
|---|---|---|
| 5 | Exceptional | Monopoly or near-monopoly, category-defining brand |
| 4 | Strong | Market leader or #1–2 in niche, durable competitive advantages |
| 3 | Adequate | Solid position but no clear moat, competitive market |
| 2 | Weak | Commoditized position, facing disruption or market share loss |
| 1 | Poor | Structural headwinds, shrinking market, no differentiation |
Strategic Rationale (20%)
| Score | Description | Indicators |
|---|---|---|
| 5 | Exceptional | Obvious value unlock — market was clearly undervaluing this business inside the parent |
| 4 | Strong | Clear rationale, both entities benefit from separation |
| 3 | Adequate | Rationale makes sense but upside is not compelling |
| 2 | Weak | Appears to be shedding a problem or forced by activist pressure |
| 1 | Poor | Clearly dumping the weaker business onto shareholders |
Management & Governance (20%)
| Score | Description | Indicators |
|---|---|---|
| 5 | Exceptional | Original CEO moves to SpinCo, full C-suite named, equity-heavy compensation with long vesting |
| 4 | Strong | Experienced CEO named, most key roles filled, meaningful equity grants tied to performance |
| 3 | Adequate | CEO named but unproven, compensation structure not yet disclosed |
| 2 | Weak | Key roles unfilled, CEO search ongoing, cash-heavy compensation |
| 1 | Poor | No leadership clarity, board turnover, no disclosed compensation plan |
Why incentives matter: In spinoffs, management compensation structure is a powerful signal. Equity-heavy comp with long vesting periods means management is betting their personal wealth on the company’s success. Options struck at low initial trading prices create built-in motivation to drive appreciation. Conversely, cash-heavy packages or golden parachutes may signal management expects a near-term sale rather than long-term independence.
Acquisition Potential (10%)
| Score | Description | Indicators |
|---|---|---|
| 5 | Exceptional | Multiple obvious acquirers, consolidating industry, acquisition premium likely |
| 4 | Strong | 2–3 credible acquirers identified, reasonable strategic fit |
| 3 | Adequate | Acquisition possible but not a primary thesis driver |
| 2 | Weak | Unlikely near-term — regulatory barriers or unattractive as a target |
| 1 | Poor | No credible buyer interest |
Grade Mapping
The five dimension scores are combined using their weights to produce a single weighted score, which maps to a letter grade:
| Weighted Score | Grade | Label |
|---|---|---|
| 4.5 – 5.0 | A+ | Top Pick |
| 4.0 – 4.4 | A | Strong Buy |
| 3.5 – 3.9 | A- | Strong Opportunity |
| 3.0 – 3.4 | B+ | Solid Opportunity |
| 2.5 – 2.9 | B | Moderate / Hold |
| 2.0 – 2.4 | B- | Speculative |
| 1.5 – 1.9 | C | Weak / Caution |
| 1.0 – 1.4 | C- | Avoid |
The grade describes the business: its finances, competitive position, rationale, management and appeal to a buyer. It does not depend on the share price. The rating, described under Ratings and Price Targets, describes the price, so a highly graded company can carry a HOLD or a TRIM when its shares are expensive.
How Grades Evolve
Spinoff grades are not static. They are re-evaluated in each report as new information becomes available.
Common triggers for grade changes:
- Form 10 filing reveals stronger or weaker financials than expected
- CEO announcement clarifies leadership quality and where the best talent is going
- Compensation disclosures reveal incentive alignment (or lack thereof)
- Timeline changes — delays may signal problems; acceleration may signal confidence
- Market developments — competitive landscape shifts, regulatory changes, industry M&A activity
When a grade changes, the scorecard in the report notes the previous grade, the new grade, and the specific reason for the change.
Handling Incomplete Information
Early-stage spinoffs often lack full disclosure. When data is unavailable for a dimension:
- That dimension is scored as 2 (assume weak until proven otherwise)
- The data gap is noted in the scorecard
- The grade is flagged as preliminary and subject to change
- The spinoff is re-scored in subsequent reports as information emerges
This conservative approach means early-stage spinoffs typically start with lower grades and can be upgraded as the investment case strengthens — which is a more useful signal for investors than giving the benefit of the doubt.
Scorecard in Practice
Every detailed spinoff analysis in our reports includes a scorecard table:
| Dimension | Weight | Score | Rationale |
|---|---|---|---|
| Financial Profile | 25% | 4 | 15.8% operating margin, stable revenue base |
| Competitive Position | 25% | 4 | Largest US LTL carrier, pure-play advantage |
| Strategic Rationale | 20% | 4 | Clear conglomerate discount removal |
| Management & Governance | 20% | 3 | Team being built, some roles TBD |
| Acquisition Potential | 10% | 3 | Possible but regulatory questions at this scale |
| Weighted Score | 3.75 | ||
| Investment Grade | A- | Strong Opportunity |
This format makes it easy to see exactly why a spinoff received its grade and which dimensions are driving the score up or down.
Ratings and Price Targets
Every company profile with a valuation carries a rating and a price target. The rating follows one scale for every company.
The price target
Each valuation is built as three scenarios: a best case, a base case and a worst case, each valued per share. Each scenario is given a probability weight, set by judgment from the evidence and disclosed on the page. The price target is the probability-weighted value of the three cases.
Two figures on each profile compare the target to the current share price:
- Expected return: the price target divided by the share price, minus one.
- Gain to loss: the probability-weighted gain from the cases worth more than the share price, divided by the probability-weighted loss from the cases worth less. A ratio of 3 to 1 means the cases above the price offer three times as much, after weighting, as the cases below it put at risk.
Both are shown as chips at the top of the profile and are recalculated on every trading day’s closing price. Each chip takes the color of the rating band the price is in, the same color as the rating badge: BUY green, ACCUMULATE blue, HOLD gold, TRIM orange and SELL red. The chips are gray while a profile is on watch or its prices have not updated.
The rating scale
| Rating | Expected return | Implied price against the target |
|---|---|---|
| BUY | +25% or more, with gain to loss of 3 to 1 or better | 20% or more below the target |
| ACCUMULATE | +10% to +25% (or +25% or more with gain to loss below 3 to 1) | 9% to 20% below the target |
| HOLD | −10% to +10% | from 9% below to 11% above the target |
| TRIM | −25% to −10% | 11% to 33% above the target |
| SELL | below −25%, or the investment case no longer holds at any price | 33% or more above the target |
The two columns state the same rule. The implied-price bands are uneven because expected return is measured from the share price, while the distance from the target is measured from the target: a price 9% below the target is a 10% expected return, and a price 11% above it is a −10% expected return.
Each profile translates the scale into dollar prices for that company, in a table of action levels (for example, BUY below $X, ACCUMULATE between $X and $Y).
How ratings are kept current
- The rating is set in each dated update on that day’s closing price, and stated with the target and the reasons for it.
- Between updates, the chips move with the price. A profile’s chips can show a band different from its rating until the next update re-rates it.
- A rating may depart from its band only with a stated reason, for example a HOLD in the TRIM band ahead of results that could change the cases. The reason is given in the rating box.
- A company whose shares could lose most of their value, such as a drug developer awaiting trial results, is valued and rated on the same scale, with its scenarios weighted by the probability of each outcome. Its rating box carries a high-risk note, because the rating does not describe how large a position should be.
- A company without a valuation yet is shown as not rated.